Ibn Warraq is the pen name of an anonymous author critical of Islam. He is the founder of the . In a review of Ibn Warraq’s book, Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism, political scientist Peter Berkowitz described. Ibn Warraq, Amherst, NY, Prometheus Books, , pp. Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism by Ibn Warraq. Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism – By Ibn Warraq. David M. Fahey. Miami University. Search for more papers by this.
|Published (Last):||9 January 2004|
|PDF File Size:||20.84 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||14.2 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
My brother and its family do not know until today that I wrote the book. Ibn Warraq continued writing with several works examining the historiography of the Qur’an and Muhammad.
I’m not comletely convinced by the author’s argument, though he makes it very cogently. This is the first systematic critique of Edward Said’s influential work, Orientalism, a book that for almost three decades has received wide acclaim, voluminous commentary, and translation into more than fifteen languages. Warraq points out Said in his fraudulent creation of the concept of “the other”, a cliche rammed down the throats of university students around the world, is never used to apply to non-Muslims or even non-Arabs in the Islamic world.
Natalie rated it did not like it Oct 15, He has described himself as an atheist  or an agnostic. Books Defending the West by Ibn Warraq.
Inthe music world saw amazing reissues spanning rock titans to indie upstarts and electronic to pop of all stripes.
The Origins of The Koran: Almost none of the waeraq facts about the study of the Middle East conform to this narrative.
Defending the West by Ibn Warraq – PopMatters
Instead, it is a Darwinian struggle where the weak are destroyed warraqq the young ever supplant the old. Archived from the original on 9 October Joe rated it it was ok Sep 19, His analysis of self-criticism is particularly important, because it shows how Western Civilization can learn from its mistakes and move forward, rather then be defined by them as Orientalism asserts.
The one aspect in which Warraq is completely successful and on which the book itself is worthwhile is his analysis that Thee was used to unfairly attack scholars and stifle discourse.
His commitment to logic and reason allow him to shred Said’s erroneous and inconsistent arguments. I had heard of the book before, but until reading it and discussing it in class had never appreciated the scope of eefending criticisms. Warraq illustrates how many artists did capture accurate portrayals of the Arab world, and that the two civilizations influenced each other in an open and fair manner.
I would highly recommend reading Said and Warraq together. Why is “rational self-criticism” inherently better than ignorance Warraq? It fefending not until I read Defending the West: This would include, for example, reinterpreting the promise of virgins in the afterlife as a promise for chilled drinks and good food. Journal of Islamic Studies.
Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism
Furthermore, Said argued that the act of discourse, defendijg the Foucalt sense of the word, is inherently ideologically-motivated and in the case of the Orientalists-scholars interested in the Orient, the Arab world-was used as a theoretical cover to justify colonialism and exploitation. One need simply consider something as banal as the Tintin comic books and their por I admit that I have never read Edward Said’s Orientalismbut references and arguments that draw from that work have definitely trickled down into many articles and comment flame wars that I am quite familiar with.
They often contended with colonialist powers on behalf of natives, and many endured great personal and financial hardship in order to carry out their work.
Language, Text and CommentaryDefending the West: View all 6 comments.
The problem with the narrative I have just described is that it is largely false. Despite his criticisms of Islamhe does not take the view that it cannot be reformed; and he works with liberal Muslims in his group.
Here again, although I disagree with the author’s convictions, it is his delivery that bothers me and that I wish to criticize. wsst
Open Preview See a Problem? Warraq has written historiographies of the early centuries of the Islamic timeline and has published works which question mainstream conceptions of the period.
Looking for More Great Reads? This section, while too nuanced to go into specifics in a review of this size, does succeed in further undermining Said and calls into question his credibility.
Defending the West: A Critique of Edward Said’s Orientalism by Ibn Warraq
During the Rushdie affairIbn Warraq noticed there were frequent critical attacks on Christianity and Judaism, but never on Islam, which – according to Warraq – tries to control every single aspect of an individual’s life, giving “no scope for independent thinking. Colonialist representations of Eastern cultures and peoples as weak, static, passive and feminized for the purposes of implying inferiority and justifying subjugation are facts that can be attested to.
I do not want that they must suffer on my account. Aug 01, Pages.
Retrieved July 17, See 2 questions about Defending the West…. Rahul Raj rated it it was amazing Oct 10,